Goodfellas Pizza

About

Pizza

Price Range : Under $10 ($)

  • star
    Yelp rating
    3 stars

Location

Adress: 6 W Union St, Athens, OH 45701

Phone: (740) 592-1572

Business info

  • list_alt
    Takes Reservations
    No
  • directions_car
    Delivery
    No
  • move_to_inbox
    Take-out
    Yes
  • credit_card
    Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • local_parking
    Parking
    Street
  • directions_bike
    Bike Parking
    No
  • accessibility
    Good for Kids
    No
  • group
    Good for Groups
    Yes
  • volume_up
    Noise Level
    Average
  • local_bar
    Alcohol
    No
  • transit_enterexit
    Outdoor Seating
    No
  • tv
    Has TV
    Yes
  • fastfood
    Caters
    No

Reviews

  • Brittany H.

    star star star star_border star_border 11 June 2026

    I'm always treated well when I come in. Super friendly staff! Unfortunately, I always feel underwhelmed when I eat here. I'm a huge pizza fan but I feel like Goodfellas pizza is mostly doughy crust. The flavor of the cheese and sauce is good, I'd just like more of it! That being said, they're open late which is convenient and you get a good amount of food for the price.

  • Rachel W.

    star star star star star 1 June 2026

    Holy cow! Get the meatball roll! It is unreal and for just $3.50! Best meatball sandwich I've ever eaten.

  • Alexandra S.

    star star star_border star_border star_border 24 May 2026

    This "pizza" is really just overpriced freshly baked bread that is way too thick for the ultra thin layer of cheese and virtually nonexistent pizza sauce.....put the proper proportion of pizza sauce on it!....major pet peeve of mine! Pizza sauce isn't expensive! It just requires the pizza maker to PAY ATTENTION TO DETAILS like putting enough freaking sauce on the dough so it's not simply cheese bread!! Keep in mind that some sauce gets soaked into the bread and spread the sauce around EVENLY and all the way around towards the edges and enough to be in proper proportion to the bread and cheese!....It's not rocket science or complicated French pastry!! And the guy working, that made and serves the slices at the counter, kind of had an attitude when I showed him that there was no sauce under the cheese and asked for a side of pizza sauce....it's called pizza, not cheese bread!! Blame yourself for not making it well, not the unsatisfied consumer!!

    This place is taking advantage of a young, naive, often drunk captive college market that is buying this crappy "pizza" because it's within walking distance to the university, dorms and bars and serves slices until 3 am. Even if that was my only option, I wouldn't go back; I'd rather just save the calories, wake up the next day and get something better. But this place has no real incentive to up its game since they've got thousands of students (during the school semesters) that will give in to their impulsive desire for warm filling bread to take the edge off their drinking buzz or hunger with no better options around, especially late at night.

  • Jenna Rose H.

    star star star star star_border 24 May 2026

    I love Goodfellas Pizza. I have ever since I came into town and tried it for the first time . Each slice is really thick and so good

  • Nick H.

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 15 May 2026

    Saw "pizza by the Slice" and assumed it was NY style. A tad bit disappointed when I saw it, even more disappointed after I took the first bite. Almost non edible.

People Recommend